This isn’t a new practice but one that has snowballed in popularity over the last few years. Fundamentally carb backloading involves a low carb carb diet upon waking until the evening part of the day from around 5pm onwards. Whereby you consume the majority of your daily carbohydrates during this time and before bed. This then often involves high protein and moderate fat meals for breakfast, lunch and snacks. Purest suggest that for this to work effectively carbs should be limited to less than 30g until the 5pm mark.
To confirm your macro split would remain the same but your carbs are consumed at night, which is the only differing element.
Pioneers of this eating strategy applaud it for its weight management benefits. Largely thought to have appetite suppressing benefits and complementing your natural insulin sensitivity fluctuations throughout a 24 hour period. In turn promoting fat loss, increasing energy and building muscle more effectively.
A study conducted by students at Cambridge University found that eating carbs predominantly at night may in fact help reduce appetite the following day. Combined with an adequate exercise regime finding also indicate favourable outcomes towards weight loss.
However before we all start having our porridge for our evening meal its worth mentioning that these studies are small and sparse, more research is needed before we begin to get really excited about the potential this eating pattern may have.
The idea of the diet is that depending on the time of day our bodies digest and absorb carbs at different rates. Which depending on when we eat carb rich foods can either be favourable or not.
Theorists suggest our bodies process carbs differently, depending on our activity. When in a rested state insulin brings more carbs to fat cells, whereas when in an active state insulin carry carbs to muscles to be used as fuel. Over time carbs sent to fat cells can lead to weight gain.
It’s thought that insulin sensitivity aligns with our bodies sleep-wake cycle (circadian rhythm). And therefore at the end of a day or after considerable movement or exercise our bodies are more adapted to “accept” and process nutrients. Therefor carb backloading is a suggested eating strategy to optimise the fuel we are eating, ensuring we use this as fuel and not store it as fat.
COACHING CONCLUSION
Before I give you my perspective, it’s important to know that my role as a coach isn’t about telling people what to do. I need to be able to highlight the pros and cons with regard to concepts and strategies and empower clients to make decisions that suit their individual needs. A good coach follows the science but is lead by clients. That said here’s my perspective on carb backloading, based on the current understandings.
Firstly when it comes to weight gain or fat loss I don’t think this approach is superior to any other form of controlled or monitored way of eating. I think that this approach would be just as affective as an even spread of your macro split. Studies have shown time and time again that the biggest driver of considerable fat loss or gain is in relation to the amount of calories you eat. Since this approach is suggesting no change until the calories or macro split I’m hedging my bets that results long term would be the same. I think another limitation to this diet style would be adherence. Some people may struggle to successfully fit this into their lifestyle and daily living.
I do though see the logic to this approach, mainly from an appetite stand point.
Heres who I feel this approach my help.
- People who struggle to regulate appetite – similarly to the keto diet (which this is like a mini version of) studies have shown limiting carbs to be favourable to appetite control. Helping people feel less hungry. Which in turn may prevent people from overeating and gaining weight. This for me is huge positive.
- People who make poor choices in the day dues a busy lifestyle or limited access to nutritious foods. EG lorry drivers, regional sales reps, office works etc.
- People who historically graze more at night. If you fall into he night time feaster category then this might be a protocol I would suggest.
Ultimately I’m neither in favour nor against this approach. If you feel it would work for you and that you can adhere to this style of eating then it absolutely is going to help keep you lean, fit and healthier. Should you wish to discuss this with me or any of our coaches then please do get in touch here.